Why “I Don’t Feel Ready to Return to Work” Is Not Valid Excuse in Ontario Personal Injury Lawsuits
In the realm of personal injury lawsuits in Ontario, especially those lawsuits based on soft-tissue or psychological injuries arising from an accident, the refrain “I don’t feel ready to return to work due to my injuries” as a justification for not returning to work often falls short in the eyes of a trier of fact. This is primarily because the legal system prioritizes objective medical evidence over subjective feelings.
Here is a closer look at why this is the case:
1. The Importance of Medical Evidence
In personal injury cases, courts and insurance companies rely heavily on medical documentation to substantiate claims. A statement from a healthcare professional detailing your condition and the reasons you cannot return to work is crucial. Without this, your claim may lack the necessary foundation to be considered valid.
2. Objective vs. Subjective Assessments
The legal process emphasizes objective assessments. This means that your ability to work is determined by medical evaluations and expert opinions rather than your personal perception of readiness. Feelings, while important, do not provide the concrete evidence required to support a legal claim.
3. Return-to-Work Policies
Employers often have return-to-work policies designed to accommodate injured employees with modified duties. If a doctor clears you for light-duty work, refusing to return without a valid medical reason could jeopardize your benefits or employment status. It’s essential to follow these policies and provide medical evidence if you are unable to comply.
4. Legal Standards and Requirements
Personal injury claims must meet specific legal standards, which include demonstrable evidence of injury and its impact on your ability to work. Subjective feelings alone do not meet these standards. The legal system requires clear, objective proof that your injury prevents you from performing your job duties.
Navigating Your Return to Work
If you genuinely feel unready to return to work, it is important to communicate this with your healthcare provider. Ensure that your concerns are documented and that you receive the appropriate medical advice and support. This documentation can then be used to substantiate your claim, providing the necessary evidence to support your case.
While your feelings about returning to work are valid and important, they must be supported by medical evidence to be considered in a personal injury lawsuit. By understanding the legal requirements and working closely with your healthcare provider, you can ensure that your claim is both valid and robust.
When you choose Porcelli D’Angela LLP, you are choosing unparalleled expertise, dedication, and personalized service. What stands out is our years of experience which has established a proven track record of success, a deep understanding of the legal landscape, and a commitment to client satisfaction. With our team of skilled legal professionals who specialize in personal injury law, Porcelli D’Angela LLP offers clients a wealth of knowledge, strategic thinking, and a relentless pursuit of justice, ensuing their legal matters are handled with the highest level of professionalism.
Call us at 647-490-944 for a free, no hassle consultation. At Porcelli D’Angela LLP, you do not pay unless you recover money.
Disclaimer: The explanations and information provided here are for general informational purposes only and are not intended to be legal advice. Always consult with a qualified lawyer or legal professional for advice specific to your situation.